Search

      On Sat., Feb. 15, the museum will be closed for a ticketed event from 10 am–1 pm and open for general admission from 1–5 pm. Learn more at pem.org/lny.

      Buy tickets
      Connected | February 4, 2025

      A Q + A with the architects who preserve and maintain Yin Yu Tang

      Dinah Cardin

      Written by

      Dinah Cardin

      Copied!

      These days, you may spot scaffolding in and around Yin Yu Tang: A Chinese Home. That’s because after more than 20 years on PEM’s campus, the house is getting some TLC. John G. Waite Associates, a leading consultant in historic preservation architecture for nearly 30 years and the firm that helped raise Yin Yu Tang in 2003, is leading repairs to the tile roof, replacing bricks and renewing the house’s white lime render coating. Preservation work may be underway during your visit, making this a rare opportunity to see this work in action. When it’s finished, the house will be prepared for at least the next 20 years.

      We sat down with Bill Brandow, a principal architect with Waite Associates, who recalls what being on the project was like more than two decades ago when the house was being re-erected brick by brick. He talks about the firm’s preservation guidelines for the current project and what work visitors might be able to see in action this spring. Visit PEM’s website for more information about the process.


      Q: Can you talk a bit about historic preservation and the goals that guide a project like this one?

      A: Ever since I was a small child, I've been interested in architecture and existing buildings more than the notion of building something from scratch. Just understanding their stories and what they tell us about people who lived there and the broader arc of history. There are preservation standards that we apply to existing buildings and judgment calls you have to make, but this Yin Yu Tang project is very different from the work we typically do. When we were first installing Yin Yu Tang more than 20 years ago, the decision was made early on to bring the building back to as close to the condition it was in when it left China. We had to come up with written standards to guide the process and then figure it out as we went. We have the general preservation standards that we apply to every project, but we've never had another project where we had to devise them fresh. There were hundreds of instances of "Do we go this way? Do we do this?" We would argue back and forth about the best way forward, but going back to those preservation standards did help answer questions that would naturally arise. The goal was to put the building back as much as possible as it was in China. But that's easier said than done!

      Q: What is your favorite memory from the process of re-erecting Yin Yu Tang back in 2003?

      A: I was involved when the house first arrived from China, going through the crates and trying to figure out how to put it back together — because there wasn't really an instruction manual with it. That was starting in late 1999. Then we finished it in June of '03, and we've been involved here and there on maintenance throughout. My favorite memory is essentially the first encounter. It was within the first couple of days when I was working on the project in the warehouse. I needed to figure out the main door hoods, how they went together, on the North side and the West side of the building. We built, basically, a large sandbox to keep everything in line, so that the bricks could be laid out, because they're all different depths. Basically, I got to play with blocks in a sandbox. It was just “figure out which brick goes where.” It had to be the exact location. You could tell if you look at the hoods now, there's damage to them that predates that, some of which was done during the Cultural Revolution, some of which was done by erosion and deterioration. I got to spend several days on the two door hoods trying to figure out how they went together and playing with blocks in sand.

      Q: What was your first impression of Yin Yu Tang?

      A: Well, it was interesting seeing it come to life, very, very slowly, but once it was finished, standing in the courtyard, just every angle of it, the sum of the rooms, the smaller spaces, you had a pretty good idea. The main courtyard was definitely the most interesting to see once it was finished. That was one where it did reveal itself fairly dramatically because you didn't get a full sense of it until the scaffolding came down. And that's when you got the appreciation of its totality. Early on, one of the ideas was to put it inside of a building to protect it. But there was a strong desire to have you experience the house as you would have in China. The best days to visit, in my opinion, are when it's raining, because it rains inside the courtyard.

      Guests in Yin Yu Tang: A Chinese Home, Peabody Essex Museum. Photo by Bob Packert/PEM.
      Guests in Yin Yu Tang: A Chinese Home, Peabody Essex Museum. Photo by Bob Packert/PEM.


      Q: How does Yin Yu Tang fit in with historic architecture in Salem and on PEM’s campus?

      A: In one sense, it doesn't. It's quite different. But in the narrative of why the Peabody Essex Museum exists and the China trade, you can see this circa 1790, 1800 merchants' house from China, and then walk around the corner and see the Gardner–Pingree House, which is from almost the exact same date and similar in size, but very different architecturally. I think that's really interesting, and there's nowhere else you can see that.

      Q: What are the preservation goals of the current Yin Yu Tang project?

      A: We’re correcting issues to specifically address Salem’s climate impact on Yin Yu Tang. The tile roof and the rendered brick are being renewed. The tile is all coming off and going back on with a tile made in the U.K. that looks the same as the Chinese tile, but that will weather better. It's from a tile company that has been in business for over 200 years. They started in business around 1806, right around the time Yin Yu Tang was built. Working through the nuance of what we wanted and needed and what they could provide that would be more hardy in a northern environment was a painstaking process, but fun. On the exterior, we're renewing the rendering. That’s the white coated surface that’s like plaster. We’re replacing the bricks below that that have failed. Then we’re recoating with a silicate coating that we used 20 years ago.

      Yin Yu Tang roof preservation

      Bill Brandow inspects roof tile samples at Dreadnought Tile in the UK. Photo by John G. Waite Associates.

      Q: Why is this preservation project happening now?

      A: A couple of years ago, we got brought back to do an envelope survey. That's the exterior envelope of the building — wall, roof, windows, doors. We were looking at the problems that had arisen, because the building is in an environment very different from the one it was originally built in over 200 years ago. We just celebrated the 20th anniversary, but the house needs a little more help than the regular maintenance that it's been getting.

      Bill Brandow inspects roof tile samples at Dreadnought Tile in the UK. Photo by John G. Waite Associates.

      Q: How does the climate in Salem differ from the climate of Yin Yu Tang’s home region, and how does that contribute to preservation challenges?

      A: A lot of the debates 20 years ago centered around how the building would hold up in this new environment. Our New England marine environment is very different from Huizhou, Anhui Province, where the house came from, which is more like the mountains of North Carolina or even Georgia — it’s further from the water and it doesn't get frost. The big difference is in marine climates, there's just more salt. Also, being on the ocean, you get heavy winds in different ways. Then the big one is freeze-thaw. The number of freeze-thaw cycles you get in Salem make it a very different environment.

      Q: What is being done now that was not implemented 20 years ago to further protect the building?

      A: We're now concealing additional flashing and additional measures to keep water out of junctures. A lot of the brick was disintegrating under the plaster and the plaster was failing because of moisture entry. Moisture migrates and freeze-thaw sets off expansion, ice crystals expand, salt crystals expand. It turns out, 20 years later, it's better to have those extra layers of defense. The decision was made to not change the basic preservation standards, but to take a slightly different angle and another crack at it and hopefully get it to a point where it can be maintained more easily.

      Yin Yu Tang: A Chinese Home, Peabody Essex Museum. Exterior. Photo by Dennis Helmar.
      Yin Yu Tang: A Chinese Home, Peabody Essex Museum. Exterior. Photo by Dennis Helmar.
      Yin Yu Tang Beam Raising Ceremony in July 2002. Photo by Wang Shukai/PEM.

      Yin Yu Tang Beam Raising Ceremony in July 2002. Photo by Wang Shukai.

      Q: What have you learned about the building in the time it has been here at the Peabody Essex Museum?

      A: We weren't going to fake anything. Everything was going to be authentic. If we blended something in, you could tell from six feet away whether it was old or new. If you didn't want to know or if you just wanted to experience it, it wasn't going to hit you over the head. If you go into the bedrooms, you could identify pretty quickly, without bending over or getting down on your hands and knees, which floorboards are original and which floorboards are new. I don't mean only architects like me can do that — anyone can notice it if I point it out. We didn't leave the new boards unpainted, but we also didn't try to make them look old. They neither detract from the experience nor fool the viewer. We tried to do the same thing on the exterior by using original roof tiles, but they haven't held up as well. We had a bunch of what we call “attic stock” to make repairs, but that stock's running out. We’re now aiming to get a new tile roof that looks as much as possible like the original but will hold up better in a northern, marine climate.

      Yin Yu Tang Beam Raising Ceremony in July 2002. Photo by Wang Shukai.

      Q: The work on the lime render will also impact the black and white murals on the exterior of the building. What can you tell us about those?

      A: Those painted details are by an artist named Yao Desheng. He's such a well-known artist in China, such an important cultural knowledge resource. None of the original painted plaster surfaces came over. His murals are in the same locations, but the subjects are quite different. They fall outside of the preservation standards in that they look very little like what was there before. It highlights the intricate nature of the Chinese-American partnership. It tells an interesting story, probably more interesting than trying to mimic exactly the murals that were there. Yao Desheng had access to all of the images of what was there, but he did not copy them. His murals were quite different from what we had been looking at for months and years on the original building, but very similar at the same time.

      Artist Yao Desheng paints murals on Yin Yu Tang's exterior in 2003. Photo by Wang Shukai/PEM.

      Artist Yao Desheng paints murals on Yin Yu Tang's exterior in 2003. Photo by Wang Shukai.

      It was fascinating watching him work, the speed at which he worked. To get the materials to hold up a little better, we used a silicate coating that has been used in Germany for 150 years. There are paintings, exterior murals that were done in the 1870s that are still intact in Germany using this product. It was interesting watching him figure out how he could make the paint do what he needed it to do. It's like hiring a watercolorist and saying, “well, you're not going to use watercolors.” These murals have held up well where there hasn't been deterioration from moisture. We've got a lot of his original murals intact, but there'll be a section missing. The hope is that he'll come back.

      Artist Yao Desheng paints murals on Yin Yu Tang's exterior in 2003. Photo by Wang Shukai.

      Q: How will the work impact the visitor experience? What can visitors expect to see?

      A: The work will obviously change the visitor experience to some extent. In our experience at Waite Associates, because we work on a lot of historic house museums and state capitals, municipal buildings, people like seeing preservation in action. They like seeing the scaffolding, what's going on, and they like hearing about it and being able to watch. There will be opportunities for that. When scaffolding goes in the main court, you won't be able to experience the house in exactly the way you can now. You'll just have a different experience. There'll be areas that'll be closed at certain times, but largely the goal is to keep it as open as possible, safely. As work progresses around the building, different parts will be inaccessible, but there'll be some sense of the progress that's being made.

      Yin Yu Tang: A Chinese Home, Peabody Essex Museum. Photo by Dennis Helmar.
      Yin Yu Tang: A Chinese Home, Peabody Essex Museum. Photo by Dennis Helmar.


      Q: What will people notice when the project is finished?

      A: Hopefully, it's more what you DON’T notice than what you do. The goal is to make it look like Yin Yu Tang 20 years ago. I don't know how much a missing roof tile jumps out to the average visitor, but you won't notice those things anymore. The change will be on the exterior, but they're not really changes. They're just renewals.

      Keep exploring

      Blog

      A Curator Travels to China and Plans for the Future of Yin Yu Tang

      7 Min read

      Art

      Yin Yu Tang: A Chinese Home

      Blog

      The Huang Legacy

      6 min read

      Blog

      Traveling Merchants Come Home: The Mid-Autumn Festival at Yin Yu Tang

      6 min read